Audio quality tests: Difference between revisions

From GC-Forever Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 223: Line 223:
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable 32kHz (2).png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU(P)-10''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable 32kHz (2).png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU(P)-10''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz.png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU-11''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz.png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU-11''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 32kHz.png|Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''Swapped L/R''}}</sup>
</gallery>
</gallery>


Line 273: Line 274:
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 32kHz.png|200px]]
|-
! YP<sub>B</sub>P<sub>R</sub>
| <span class="plainlinks">[https://files.extremscorner.org/gamecube/audio/comparisons/PCM1862/Retro-Bit%20Retro%20Prism%20Component%20Cable%2032kHz.flac Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable]</span><br /><sup>{{nowrap|''Swapped L/R''}}</sup>
| [[File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 32kHz.png|200px]]
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 32kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 32kHz.png|200px]]
|}
|}


Line 584: Line 591:
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable 48kHz (2).png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU(P)-10''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable 48kHz (2).png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU(P)-10''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz.png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU-11''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz.png|Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''With DOL-CPU-11''}}</sup>
File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 48kHz.png|Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable <br /> <sup>{{nowrap|''Swapped L/R''}}</sup>
</gallery>
</gallery>


Line 634: Line 642:
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable 48kHz.png|200px]]
|-
! YP<sub>B</sub>P<sub>R</sub>
| <span class="plainlinks">[https://files.extremscorner.org/gamecube/audio/comparisons/PCM1862/Retro-Bit%20Retro%20Prism%20Component%20Cable%2048kHz.flac Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable]</span><br /><sup>{{nowrap|''Swapped L/R''}}</sup>
| [[File:DA ALL AVG mdfourier-dac-48000 vs PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 48kHz.png|200px]]
| [[File:NF SP B PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 48kHz -1Silence.png|200px]]
| [[File:T SP B PCM1862 Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable 48kHz.png|200px]]
|}
|}



Revision as of 11:20, 27 May 2022

Disclosures

  • EON GCHD Mk-II was provided by EON Gaming.
  • HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable was provided by HD Retrovision.
  • Insurrection Industries CARBY was provided by Insurrection Industries.
  • Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable was provided by CastleMania Games.
  • RetroTINK-5X Pro was provided by RetroTINK.

32kHz sample rate

Using MDFourier 1.08 with this reference file.

The 32kHz sample rate is most commonly used by licensed software. It is upsampled to 48kHz in hardware prior to final output.
The nominal sample rate is 54MHz÷1124, rather than 54MHz÷1125. This is reflected in the frame duration of the standard equipment test.

A 15kHz white screen was displayed to induce audible noise.

ASUS PRIME X570-PRO & ProArt X570-CREATOR WIFI

Using ALC1220 (S1220A).

This sound card serve as our analog reference.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R

Blackmagic Intensity Shuttle

Using CS42526 and ADV7604.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
Y/C Hyperkin 3-in-1 HDTV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R
TMDS GCVideo-DVI v3.1
TMDS GCVideo-DVI v3.1
Sample Rate Hack [1]

Hauppauge WinTV-HVR-1850

Using CX23888.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo RF Modulator
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11

Open Source Scan Converter

Using PCM1862.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R

RetroTINK-5X Pro

Using PCM1808.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11

48kHz sample rate

Using MDFourier 1.08 with this reference file.

The 48kHz sample rate is most commonly used by homebrew software and streaming audio in licensed software.
The nominal sample rate is 54MHz÷1124, rather than 54MHz÷1125. This is reflected in the frame duration of the standard equipment test.

A 15kHz white screen was displayed to induce audible noise.

ASUS PRIME X570-PRO & ProArt X570-CREATOR WIFI

Using ALC1220 (S1220A).

This sound card serve as our analog reference.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R

Blackmagic Intensity Shuttle

Using CS42526 and ADV7604.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
Y/C Hyperkin 3-in-1 HDTV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R
TMDS GCVideo-DVI v3.1
TMDS GCVideo-DVI v3.1
Sample Rate Hack [1]

Hauppauge WinTV-HVR-1850

Using CX23888.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo RF Modulator
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11

Open Source Scan Converter

Using PCM1862.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Retro-Bit Retro Prism Component Cable
Swapped L/R

RetroTINK-5X Pro

Using PCM1808.

Source Difference Noise floor Time spectrogram
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable
Swapped L/R
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter
DC Offset + Sample Rate Hack [1]
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
YPBPR Nintendo GameCube Component Video Cable + Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11

Instrument measurements

SIGLENT SDS1104X-E

1000Hz tone
Source VPP VMax VMin VRMS
L R L R L R L R
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
5.40 5.36 2.68 2.64 -2.72 -2.72 1.81 1.81
CVBS Nintendo Stereo AV Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
5.36 5.36 2.64 2.64 -2.72 -2.72 1.81 1.81
Y/C Generic S-Video Cable
With DOL-CPU-11
5.44 5.40 2.68 2.68 -2.76 -2.72 1.82 1.81
RGBCVS HD Retrovision SNES Component Cable
With DOL-CPU(P)-10
5.36 5.36 2.64 2.64 -2.72 -2.72 1.81 1.81
YPBPR Bitfunx/Kaico GameCube Component Cable 5.80 5.88 2.88 2.92 -2.92 -2.96 1.95 1.99
YPBPR GCVideo-DVI v3.1 + Portta HDMI to YPbPr Converter 2.40 2.40 1.20 1.20 -1.20 -1.20 0.787 0.788